Partitive Articles

Nastia B.A2Kwiziq community member

Partitive Articles

If I am sure about which salad I am eating, I would still say 'Je mange de la salade,' 'Je mange une salade,' or 'Je mange la salade.' What is the difference?

Asked 3 weeks ago
Chris W.C1 Kwiziq Q&A super contributor Correct answer

Here's the difference between these three ways of referring to a salad you're eating:

Je mange de la salade. -- This emphasizes the general substance/food type. More like "I'm eating salad" (as a type of food). It focuses on the act of eating salad in general.

Je mange une salade. -- This emphasizes that it's one complete salad/serving. More like "I'm eating a salad" (as a dish). Focuses on it being a single, complete portion,

Je mange la salade. -- This refers to a specific salad that has been previously mentioned or is known in context. More like "I'm eating the salad" (that particular one). Could be used, for example, if someone made a salad for the meal and you're eating it, or if you're eating the salad you ordered.

Jim J.C1 Kwiziq Q&A super contributor

Salut Nastia,

This is tricky because it depends on what you are referring to.

1) Are you referring to a meal you already started and want to complete eating? --> La salade.

2) Are you planning to make such a meal from scratch? --> Je prépare des salade (some) 

(You are bringing together all of the ingredients required)

3) Are you placing an order in a restaurant --> Je vais prendre de la salade.

I would be interested in seeing others' comments on this issue. This is how I understand it and hope that it helps.

Bonne continuation,

Jim

Partitive Articles

If I am sure about which salad I am eating, I would still say 'Je mange de la salade,' 'Je mange une salade,' or 'Je mange la salade.' What is the difference?

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your French level for FREE

Test your French to the CEFR standard

Find your French level
I'll be right with you...