j'ai toujours eu or j'avais?

Carl C.C1Kwiziq Q&A regular contributor

j'ai toujours eu or j'avais?

Why do we use j'ai toujours eu for "I have always had"? My understanding is the passe' compose' of avoir implies "I got" more than "I had". If we want to say "I had" we should use j'avais.

This question relates to:French writing exercise "Which book to choose?"

Freeform Writing Exercise C1

Asked 3 months ago

Like1Answer1

CélineNative French expert teacher in KwiziqCorrect answer

Bonjour Carl,

- Passé Composé:

J'ai toujours eu... = I've always had...

-> the action started in the past and still occurs (due to the presence of "toujours")

- Imparfait:

J'avais toujours... = I always had (used to have)...

-> the action was recurring in the past but stopped ages ago.

Take a look at this similar query: Imparfait vs Passé Compose

I hope this is helpful.

Bonne journée !

Like13 months ago

Carl C. asked:View original

j'ai toujours eu or j'avais?

Why do we use j'ai toujours eu for "I have always had"? My understanding is the passe' compose' of avoir implies "I got" more than "I had". If we want to say "I had" we should use j'avais.

Don't have an account yet? Join today

« "pendant que" avec le subjonctif?Is 'être' incorrect in this context? »

Ask a question

Find your French level for FREE

Test your French to the CEFR standard

Find your French level